Menu of A Taste of Seafood in New York, USA

Menu Overview

A Taste of Seafood, nestled at 2 W 125th St in New York, is a standout destination for seafood lovers craving authentic soul food with a modern twist. This takeout-focused spot perfectly balances quality, flavor, and tradition, offering an extensive menu that highlights the best of Southern-inspired seafood dishes alongside beloved sides and desserts.

The menu’s crown jewel is undoubtedly their Taste of Seafood platter, which showcases perfectly fried fish like catfish, flounder, and shrimp, each prepared with a seasoned, crisp breading that avoids any heaviness or starchy aftertaste. The catfish here, in particular, was praised as “the best in the world” by a loyal patron, and it’s easy to see why. It’s golden, flavorful, and cooked just right, delivering that authentic soul food experience in every bite.

Another remarkable dish is the Catfish & Shrimp Macaroni and Cheese with Collard Greens. This combo marries creamy, cheesy macaroni with succulent seafood and perfectly cooked collards, a trifecta that comforts and satisfies. The mac and cheese stands out with its rich texture, complementing rather than overpowering the delicate seafood.

The breakfast menu, featuring soulful staples like Catfish Fish & Grits, Shrimp & Grits, and even indulgent options like Chicken Wings & Waffles and Lobster Tails & Grits, offers a unique spin on early-day dining. These dishes are hearty, flavorful, and crafted to energize, reflecting a true Southern brunch vibe in the heart of Harlem.

For those with a sweet tooth, their Chocolate Layer Cake provides a comforting, rich finish to any meal, though it’s wise to note that occasional mix-ups do happen, as noted by some customers. Still, the quality remains consistent.

Customer reviews point to the authenticity and quality of A Taste of Seafood’s offerings. For instance, the salmon soup special—a creamy, seafood-packed bowl priced reasonably at $10—caught a first-time visitor’s delight, highlighting the attentive care in their kitchen. And while this location is cash-only and operates strictly as a takeout spot, the convenience and quality more than makeup for the lack of dine-in options.

On the sides front, signature dishes like the southern potato salad, candied yams, and cornbread are not mere accompaniments but integral parts of the experience. Each side captures the deep, soulful flavors integral to Southern cuisine and complements the seafood beautifully.

In summary, A Taste of Seafood is a reliable gem in Harlem for those seeking authentic, well-seasoned fried fish and seafood, served alongside classic soul food sides. It maintains a straight-forward approach—no frills, just honest food prepared with care. Whether it’s a crave-worthy catfish sandwich, a robust fish and shrimp macaroni and cheese, or a comforting bowl of grits with seafood, this spot delivers soulful satisfaction that keeps patrons coming back.

Contact and visit: 2 W 125th St, New York, NY 10027 | +1 646-476-6847